Should You Switch PPC Agencies? How to Tell Before You Leave

Summarize with AI

How a Unified Data Approach Boosts Marketing ROI

Your leads or sales have been down for a few months. But on your weekly call, your agency may say things like “overall, trending well” or that “the algorithm just needs some time.” Now you’re starting to wonder if you seriously need to consider switching PPC agencies to get things back on track.

But before you write the breakup email, you need to make sure switching agencies actually fixes what’s frustrating you and helps you get where you want to go. This guide walk you through agency dealbreakers and how to know when to switch, and when to stay.

Most agency frustration deserves a conversation first. But the presence of these four dealbreakers warrants no conversation. They’re not “results are down” problems. They’re “this is how we work” problems, and giving them another quarter won’t change who they are.

(If you want the longer list of warning signs, we wrote 15 signs your Google Ads agency is wasting your budget.)

1. Nobody’s touching the account. Google Ads keeps a change history. It shows who changed what and when. Take a look for yourself. If it’s been weeks without activity, you’re paying a management fee for autopilot.

2. There’s no real direction. Ask them what they’re testing next quarter and why. A good agency has an answer tied to your goals. “We’ll keep optimizing” is not an answer. It’s a placeholder. And don’t mistake activity for direction. Touching an account too much can be just as bad as not touching it at all. It just signals a different type of problem.

3. They won’t collaborate. You know things that never show up in an ad account, like which leads actually close, which services drive your margin, when your slow season hits, and importantly, what your priorities are. If you tell them and nothing changes, you don’t have a partner. You have a vendor.

4. Their strategy is just Google’s to-do list. Every Google Ads account has an optimization score and a list of recommendations. Some are worthwhile. Many of them push bigger budgets, broader targeting, and more automation. And they’re coming from the company that makes money when you spend more. A good agency checks each one against your goals before hitting “apply.”

Let’s say your agency is engaged. They’re tracking the right metrics. They respond to your emails and phone calls promptly. You may even really like the people you work with. But results are still down, and at the end of the day, that reflects on you. What now?

First question: how long has performance been down, and can you explain it?

If results dipped for a month or two, don’t change anything yet. The same goes if the dip lines up with your slow season, a rough patch in the economy, or something everyone in your industry is feeling. Pull up last year’s numbers for the same months. Ask a couple of peers how their phones are ringing, or ask your agency to share anonymized performance from similar clients. If everybody’s down, your agency didn’t cause it, and a new one won’t fix it.

Now, if results have been down for six months to a year and nothing backs it up? No seasonal pattern. No market shift. Competitors seem fine. That’s different. That’s the point where we’d give your agency one last 30 to 60 day window.

And use those 30 to 60 days to quietly shop around. Talk to a few agencies. Get a second opinion on your account. That way, if nothing changes, you’re not starting a search from scratch with your results still sliding. And if your agency does turn it around? No harm done. You’ve simply learned what else is out there.

You should see the effort right away. A written plan. Activity in the account. Better questions about your business. The results take longer. But if 60 days go by with no plan, no changes, and the same excuses? Now you know. You gave them a fair shot, and you already have options lined up.

Need a second opinion?

We specialize in high-ROI lead generation for regional businesses as a partner to marketing leaders and owners.

If that’s you, request a free PPC audit and one-hour strategy session. No obligation. Worst case, a free second opinion.

Sometimes the agency is fine and the problem is somewhere else. If that’s you, a new agency inherits the exact same issues and spends its first few months just finding them.

Before you switch, take an honest look at your side:

  • Your tracking. Are calls, forms, and booked jobs actually being counted? If it was set up years ago and nobody owns it now, start there. A good agency should spot tracking issues, but if they can’t see your CRM (your customer database), they can’t be held responsible when something breaks there.
  • Your website. Great ads can’t save a slow page or a form nobody wants to fill out. A good agency should recommend, or even own, landing page creation. If you own it, consider why.
  • Your follow-up. If calls go to voicemail or leads sit for two days, the ads aren’t your problem.
  • Your budget vs. your goals. If your budget can’t cover what clicks cost in your market, every agency you hire is going to disappoint you.
  • Your market. New competitors, a slow season, rising costs. Those drag results down no matter who’s running the account.

And if you’ve already switched agencies once or twice for the same reason? Be honest with yourself about that. The common thread might not be the agency.

A marketing director from a multi-location healthcare group came to us after their agency wasn’t making progress. She felt like they weren’t collaborating with her, and she wanted a second opinion before making a decision, so we audited the account.

First surprise: the account wasn’t neglected. Budgets and bidding had changed 20 times in 81 days. Somebody was definitely busy.

But busy isn’t the same as having a plan. Here’s what we found:

Offline conversions were supposed to be imported, and no one was checking whether they were. Patients filled out 42 booking forms in 30 days. That action wasn’t connected to a single campaign in the account. There was a nightly import from their customer database that was supposed to fill the gap. It reported “Completed” every night for eight nights straight while bringing in zero records. That’s an agency that hadn’t checked its conversions in over a week.

There was no way to steer the budget, despite having location-specific goals. One campaign covered 144 location targets on one budget. So you couldn’t put more behind one city and less behind another.

35% of the new-patient budget went to pages where patients couldn’t book.

A landing page test spent $12,225 over 30 days and got three conversions. Google’s own report said there wasn’t enough data to draw any conclusion.

Now look at that list again. It’s a mix. The tracking setup, customer data, and the test design are on whoever runs the account. The single landing page sits partly on the business side, but it’s up to the agency to flag it. Together, this was enough for the marketing director to know she needed a different partner.

Plenty of business owners and marketing managers change agencies about every two years, usually because performance comes in cycles. Spend a few minutes in any small business forum and you’ll see how often businesses switch at the first sign of trouble.

You have a great year. The next year doesn’t beat it, so you switch. The year after that, results bounce back, and the new agency looks like a genius.

But was it the new agency? Or was it just the next year in the cycle?

Our team averages more than 10 years of experience, which adds up to a lot of accounts and a lot of years, good and bad. We’ve audited accounts for businesses that hop agencies regularly. And across our careers, including time at other agencies, we’ve seen clients leave during an off year, and seen clients stay through one, only to rebound the next.

Marketing has ebbs and flows. There will be down years no matter who’s running your account. A down year by itself isn’t a reason to switch. It’s a reason to ask questions, check it against the market, and see if your agency has a thoughtful strategy for it.

That’s why the real goal isn’t finding the agency that never has a bad year. That agency doesn’t exist. It’s finding a partner you trust enough to ride out the dips with, so you’re not starting over every time the numbers soften.

If you’ve decided to go, read how to switch PPC agencies first. It covers how to keep your accounts, your data, and your momentum. And before you choose the next one, how to tell if a digital ad agency knows what it’s doing gives you the questions to ask.

If you’re on the fence, a second opinion costs far less than a switch.

We’ll review your account for free, tell you what we see, and be straightforward about what’s the agency’s responsibility and what isn’t. Sometimes the answer is “your agency just needs a nudge.” We’ll tell you that too.

Request a free PPC account audit, or take the PPC Audit Quiz if you’d like to explore on your own first. Either way, let’s talk.

Q1: How long should I give my current PPC agency to fix things?

Ans: It depends on two things: how long results have been down, and whether you can explain why.

If it’s been a month or two, or the dip lines up with your slow season or a rough patch in the economy, you don’t need a deadline yet. That’s normal movement, and switching in the middle of it usually just resets the clock.

If results have been down for six months to a year and nothing outside the account explains it, that’s when we’d set a deadline. Have one clear conversation, put it in writing, and give them one last 30 to 60 days. Use that time to quietly talk to other agencies, so you’re ready either way.

And if you’re dealing with any of the four dealbreakers? There’s no window. Those don’t improve with time.

Q2: My agency makes changes all the time. Doesn’t that mean they’re working hard?

Ans: Not necessarily. Activity and direction aren’t the same thing.

In the account from our real-life example, budgets and bidding changed 20 times in 81 days. On paper, that looks like an engaged agency. In reality, there was no stable stretch long enough to judge whether any of those changes worked, and no clear plan connecting them.

Constant changes can be just as damaging as no changes at all. Google Ads needs time and consistent data to learn what’s working. Every major change starts that process over.

So instead of asking how often your agency is in the account, ask what each change was meant to accomplish and how they’ll know if it worked. A good agency can answer that quickly. If nobody can, that’s your answer.

Q3: Is it a red flag if my agency follows Google’s recommendations?

Ans: Only if that’s all they do.

Google’s recommendations aren’t all bad. Some catch real issues, like a broken ad or a budget that’s limiting a strong campaign. But many of them nudge you toward bigger budgets, broader targeting, and more automation. And they come from the company that earns more when you spend more.

That doesn’t make Google the villain. It just means the recommendations are written for Google’s goals as much as yours.

A good agency treats them as suggestions, not instructions. They review each one against your goals, apply the ones that make sense, and dismiss the rest. Ask your agency to walk you through a few recommendations they turned down and why. If they can’t name any, they’re probably clicking “apply” across the board.

Q4: How do I know if a down year is the agency or just the cycle?

Ans: Start by looking outside your own account.

Pull up the same months from last year and the year before. If you see the same dip, it’s probably seasonal. Then talk to a few peers in your industry and ask how their phones are ringing. If everyone’s feeling it, your agency didn’t cause it.

You can also ask your agency to share anonymized performance from similar clients. A good agency manages enough accounts to tell you whether what you’re seeing is a pattern or a problem specific to you.

If you’re down and everyone around you seems fine, that’s a different conversation. That’s when it’s worth digging into the account itself, and possibly getting a second opinion.

Q5: Can I get a second opinion without telling my agency?

Ans: Yes, as long as you own your Google Ads account. You can add an auditor with read-only access, which lets them see everything without changing anything.

If you can’t add users yourself, pay attention to that. It often means the agency owns the account, and that’s worth sorting out whether you switch or not.

When you do get an audit, make sure the auditor can see where your leads actually end up, not just the ads. Some of the biggest problems we find sit between the ad and your customer database. In our real-life example, a nightly import reported “Completed” for eight straight nights while bringing in zero records. That’s the kind of issue you won’t spot by looking at the ad account alone.

Q6: Will a new agency just tear everything down and start over?

Ans: A good one won’t.

Your account has history: what’s worked, what hasn’t, and what your customers actually respond to. Throwing that out on day one means paying to relearn it.

Before we touch a single campaign, we sit down with the client and agree on what a good lead is and what it’s worth. Sometimes we start with an even bigger question, like we did with the client in our real-life example: is PPC even the right channel for this business? Only then do we decide what to keep, what to fix, and what to rebuild.

If an agency pitches you a complete overhaul before they’ve seen your data, take that as a warning sign. Our guide on how to switch PPC agencies covers what a smooth handoff should look like.

About Author
NPD Graphics 02
CTA Logo 1